A credit spread strategy is one of the most reliable ways to trade options with defined risk, consistent probabilities, and steady income potential. Instead of trying to predict big market moves, credit spreads let you profit when the market simply behaves as expected — staying flat, drifting slightly higher, or fading off resistance.
That’s why professional traders rely on bull put spreads and bear call spreads as their foundation for short-premium trading on SPX and SPY.
With the right strike placement and disciplined exits, a credit spread strategy gives you clear risk, clear reward, and a 60–85% probability of success.
In this guide, I’ll break down exactly how the strategy works, when to use it, how to select strikes, and how to manage risk like a pro, with real examples pulled from the same logic I use in my automated systems.
Why this works: With the right strike selection and timing, a credit spread lets you get paid for being approximately right, not perfectly right, while keeping risk capped.
Table of Contents
hide
Are Credit Spreads a Good Strategy?
Yes — credit spreads are one of the most consistently profitable options strategies when used correctly. They benefit from time decay, allow traders to sell premium far from current price, and keep risk strictly defined. This makes them especially effective in neutral or mildly trending markets where price isn’t expected to move aggressively.
The key advantage is probability: you can structure spreads with a 60–85% chance of expiring worthless while still maintaining controlled risk and mechanical exits.
What Is the Credit Spread Strategy? (Quick Refresher)
A credit spread is an options position where you sell one option and simultaneously buy another option on the same underlying and expiration, at a different strike. The sale brings in more premium than the purchase, so you collect a net credit. Your max profit is that credit; your max loss is the strike width minus the credit.
A credit spread strategy lets you get paid for being approximately right—not perfectly right.
You collect premium upfront, risk is capped, and time decay works in your favour.
You collect premium upfront, risk is capped, and time decay works in your favour.
What Are Common Credit Spread Strategies?
Bull Put Spread (Mildly Bullish)
- Sell higher-strike put; buy lower-strike put (same expiry).
- Profit if price stays above the short strike or time/vol decay helps.
- Common on SPX/SPY when trend is up or range holds.
Bear Call Spread (Mildly Bearish)
- Sell lower-strike call; buy higher-strike call (same expiry).
- Profit if price stays below the short strike or rallies fade.
- Useful in weak or choppy tape when rallies keep failing.
When to Use Credit Spreads
I deploy the credit spread strategy when probabilities and pricing tilt in my favor—typically during neutral to mildly directional markets with supportive volatility. Here’s the practical checklist I use before selling a bull put or bear call on SPX:1) Market Context (Price Action First)
- Mildly bullish / range-holding: consider a bull put spread beneath recent support.
- Mildly bearish / fading rallies: consider a bear call spread above resistance.
- Avoid placing new spreads directly into binary catalysts (FOMC, CPI) unless that is part of your plan.
2) Implied Volatility (Get Paid for Risk)
- Prefer elevated but not extreme IV. Higher IV generally pays better credits and more distance from price.
- When IV is very low, I either move further out (time) or skip the trade—thin credits aren’t worth the tail risk.
3) Liquidity & Execution
- Stick to liquid underlyings and expirations (tight bid-ask, active series). SPX and SPY are ideal.
- Use limit orders and avoid chasing fills; slippage quietly taxes your edge.
Pro tip: I typically close spreads at 50–60% of max profit, but you can also hold until the last 3–5 DTE. It can increases late-cycle gamma risk and can create surprise assignment on American-style ETFs like SPY.
Want concrete numbers? In the next section we’ll walk through SPX/ETF credit spread examples with strike selection and risk/reward math, and I’ll show where I place short strikes relative to recent support/resistance.
Bull Put vs Bear Call Use-Cases
| Market condition | Best spread | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Range-bound | Either | Sell outside support/resistance |
| Mildly bullish | Bull put spread | Price expected to stay above support |
| Mildly bearish | Bear call spread | Price expected to stay below resistance |
| High IV | Both | Higher premiums + more strike distance |
| Pre-catalyst | Avoid spreads | Harder to model risk |
How to Set Up a Credit Spread & Pick Strikes (Step-by-Step)
My process is simple and repeatable. The goal is to sell premium where price is unlikely to go, collect a solid credit, and keep risk capped. Here’s the checklist I use on SPX/SPY every week:1) Choose the Spread Type
- Bull Put Spread for mildly bullish or range-bound markets (sell put closer to price; buy a further OTM put).
- Bear Call Spread for mildly bearish or mean-reverting rallies (sell call closer to price; buy a further OTM call).
2) Time to Expiration (DTE)
- I prefer 30–45 DTE for smoother theta and easier management.
- For faster turnover, 21–30 DTE is fine if liquidity is excellent.
3) Strike Distance & Probability
- Anchor short strikes near ~0.05–0.10 delta (or use your preferred POP threshold).
- Place them beyond obvious support/resistance zones on the daily chart.
4) Credit, Width & Risk/Reward
- Target a credit that gives you at least 1:2 risk/reward (max loss ≈ 2× max profit or better).
- Remember: Max Profit = Net Credit; Max Loss = Width − Credit.
5) Exit & Risk Rules
- Take profits around 50–60% of max profit; close 3–5 DTE to avoid gamma/assignment risk.
- Size each trade at ~1–5% of account risk; keep a buying-power buffer for volatility spikes.
Example #1: SPX Bull Put Spread (Mildly Bullish)
This is my base case when price is trending up or holding a range above support.Setup
- Underlying: SPX
- Assume Price: 5100
- Expiry: ~35 DTE
- Strikes: Sell 5150 put / Buy 5140 put (width = 10)
- Credit Received: 5.00
Math
- Max Profit: 5.00
- Max Loss: 10 − 5.00 = 5.00
- Breakeven: Short strike − credit = 5145
- Risk/Reward: 5.00 : 5.00 ≈ 1 : 1
Why This Works
- Short strike sits below recent support and below the 20–50 DMA cluster.
- Elevated IV improves credit and distance.
- Defined risk; easy to automate exits at 50–60% of max profit.
Management: Scale out at 50–60% of max profit; close entirely if price closes below support or IV spikes through resistance. Try not to hold inside the last 3–5 DTE.
Example #2: SPY Bear Call Spread (Mildly Bearish)
I like this when rallies look tired and keep failing under a known resistance level.Setup
- Underlying: SPY
- Assume Price: 505.00
- Expiry: ~30 DTE
- Strikes: Sell 500 call / Buy 501 call (width = 1)
- Credit Received: 0.50
Math
- Max Profit: 0.50
- Max Loss: 1 − 0.50 = 0.50
- Breakeven: Short strike + credit = 515.50
- Risk/Reward: 0.50 : 0.50 ≈ 1 : 1
Why This Works
- Short call is set above resistance with rallies failing to break/hold.
- Neutral-to-bearish tape + reasonable IV supports quicker decay.
- Defined risk with straightforward exits and assignment awareness (SPY is American-style).
Note on Assignment: Because SPY is American-style, early assignment is possible near ex-dividend or late in the cycle. Manage proactively and avoid holding into the last few days.
Risk Management & Credit Spread Probability of Profit
Successful traders don’t predict — they prepare. The edge in credit spreads isn’t in calling market tops or bottoms; it’s in managing position size and timing exits with discipline.My Risk Rules
- Risk 1–5% of account per trade. This ensures that even consecutive losers can’t destroy capital.
- Close early at 50–60% of max profit. Don’t get greedy — you reduce gamma and event risk.
- Avoid selling cheap premiums. If IV is low and credits are tiny, skip the trade.
- Monitor your short strike. If price crosses it, adjust or exit — fast. Hope is not a strategy.
What Is the Best Strategy for Put Credit Spreads?
The best approach for put credit spreads is to sell a bull put spread below a strong support zone, ideally at a delta between 0.05–0.15. This places your short strike in an area the market is unlikely to test while still delivering a solid credit.
Professional traders prefer:
-
30–45 DTE for smoother decay
-
Exiting at 50–60% max profit
-
Avoiding weeks with major macro events
-
Defined width (so risk is capped regardless of volatility spikes)
In SPX/SPY, this setup consistently outperforms because liquidity ensures tight fills and predictable behaviour.
Credit Spread vs. Debit Spread
Traders often confuse credit spreads with debit spreads. Both are defined-risk option structures, but their objectives — and their cash flows — are opposite.| Feature | Credit Spread | Debit Spread |
|---|---|---|
| Cash Flow | Receive premium | Pay premium |
| Goal | Earn from time decay | Profit from directional move |
| Ideal Market | Neutral to slow | Trending strongly |
| Risk | Limited to width − credit | Limited to premium paid |
Defined-Risk Options Trading: Why It Works
Defined-risk trading is the foundation of longevity. Every time I sell a spread, I know my exact dollar risk and my maximum reward before the order fills. That allows me to scale consistently, manage stress, and avoid catastrophic drawdowns. Here’s what makes defined-risk spreads so powerful:- Predictable outcomes: You know both your cap and your floor.
- Consistency: Frequent small wins compound steadily over time.
- Emotional control: Pre-defined exits eliminate panic decisions.
“You don’t need to predict the market; you just need to define your risk and let time work for you.”Want to automate this discipline? Learn how our system executes SPX and SPY credit spreads with rule-based precision: Credit Spread Signals – Advanced AutoTrades.
Automation and Execution (Advanced AutoTrades)
Even the best trading plan fails if execution is sloppy or emotional. That’s why automation has become a major edge for retail traders. I’ve seen it firsthand—many traders lose not because the strategy is bad, but because they hesitate, overtrade, or ignore exit rules. Automated systems like those used by Advanced AutoTrades execute SPX and SPY credit spreads with precise rules: correct strike distance, defined risk, and mechanical exits. Automation doesn’t trade more—it trades better.
Benefits of automation:
If you’d like to see live examples of automated SPX credit spreads with verified performance, check out Credit Spread Signals – Advanced AutoTrades.
- Removes hesitation and emotional bias.
- Executes with consistent position sizing and stop rules.
- Improves fill quality by acting faster during liquidity windows.
- Lets you focus on strategy selection instead of order entry.
